Choosing a Locksmith
Buying Locks: Locksmith Shop vs. Hardware Store
The differences between locks sold at big-box stores and locks from a locksmith, including quality grades, key control and installation.
Updated November 21, 2026 · 3 min read · Arrowhead Lock & Safe
Not all locks are equal
A deadbolt from a big-box store and a deadbolt from a locksmith can look similar, but they're often built very differently. Retail locks are designed to hit a price point and be easy to install. Locksmith-grade locks use heavier materials, tighter tolerances and stronger bolts, and some offer restricted keys that can't be copied at a kiosk.
Grades and ratings
Locks are tested to industry grades for durability and strength. Higher grades withstand more cycles and more force. Many retail residential locks are lower grade, which is fine for interior doors but less ideal for an exterior door that faces the street. Locksmiths can explain the grade of each option.
Key control
Locks bought at retail use common keyways that anyone can copy. Locksmiths can supply locks on restricted keyways, so only an authorized dealer can make copies. That's valuable for homes with frequent visitors, rental properties and businesses.
Keying and compatibility
When you buy locks from a locksmith, they can be keyed to match your existing keys or to a master key system before installation. Retail locks come with random keys, and mixing brands often means multiple keys on your ring.
Installation and support
A locksmith installs the lock correctly, adjusts the strike so the bolt fully engages and checks the door for problems that weaken security. If something goes wrong later, you have someone to call.
When retail locks make sense
For interior doors, closets and low-risk applications, a retail lock is often fine. For exterior doors, businesses and any door protecting something valuable, a locksmith-grade lock is usually worth the difference.
Matching finishes and styles
Locksmiths can supply locks in finishes and styles that match your existing hardware or a renovation plan, including levers, knobs and handle sets for both residential and commercial doors. If you want hardware that looks consistent across every door, buying from one source and keying it together avoids mismatched finishes and multiple keys.
For commercial buildings, standardizing on one brand and function also simplifies future repairs, because parts and cylinders are interchangeable.
Warranty and parts
Locksmith-grade hardware typically comes with stronger warranties and long-term parts availability. If a lever breaks or a cylinder wears, it can be repaired rather than replaced. Retail locks are often designed to be replaced entirely when something breaks. Over the life of a door, especially a busy one, repairable hardware usually costs less.
Shop locks in Atlanta
Arrowhead's shop on Cumberland Parkway stocks residential and commercial locks, high-security cylinders and Medeco products, and can key them to your needs. Call 404-351-4331 or stop by on a weekday.
Frequently asked questions
Are big-box locks bad?
Not necessarily, but many are lower grade and use keyways anyone can copy.
Can a locksmith key new locks to my old key?
Often, if the locks share a compatible keyway.
What's a restricted keyway?
A key system where blanks are only available to authorized dealers, preventing unauthorized copies.
Do locksmith locks cost more?
Often, but they last longer and offer better security and key control.
Can I buy a lock and install it myself?
Yes. We can key it for you first so it matches your other locks.
Can you match my existing door hardware finish?
Usually. Bring a photo or the brand name and we'll find a match.