Home & Residential Locks
Rekeying vs. Changing Locks: How to Decide
How rekeying works, when it beats replacing locks, what it costs compared with new hardware, and how homes and businesses decide.
Updated November 17, 2026 · 3 min read · Arrowhead Lock & Safe
What rekeying actually does
Every pin-tumbler lock has a set of small pins inside the cylinder. The key lifts those pins to exactly the right heights so the cylinder can turn. Rekeying replaces the pins with a new set that matches a new key. The lock stays on the door, the hardware looks the same, but every old key stops working.
Changing the locks means removing the hardware and installing new locks. You get new keys too, but you also get new hardware, which is the point when the old locks are worn or weak.
When rekeying is the right choice
Rekey when the locks work smoothly and you're happy with their quality, but you don't know who has keys. That covers moving into a new home, a lost or stolen key, a tenant or employee who didn't return keys, and roommates or relationships that have ended.
Rekeying is also how you get one key for every door. Compatible locks can be rekeyed alike, so the front door, back door and garage entry all use the same key.
When changing the locks makes more sense
Change the locks when the hardware is the problem: a lock that sticks, a deadbolt that won't fully extend, a cylinder that spins, damage from a break-in, or cheap hardware that doesn't belong on an exterior door. Replacing is also the way to upgrade, such as moving to a heavier deadbolt, a commercial-grade lock on a business door, or a high-security cylinder whose keys can't be copied without authorization.
Mismatched brands and keyways can also push you toward replacement, since not every lock can be rekeyed to match every other one.
How the cost compares
Rekeying is usually much less expensive than replacement because you're paying for labor and new keys, not new hardware. Replacement adds the price of the locks themselves, which varies widely with brand and grade.
The cheapest choice isn't always the best value. Rekeying a worn-out lock means paying again when it fails. A good locksmith will tell you which locks are worth rekeying and which should be replaced, and many jobs end up being a mix of both.
Rekeying for businesses
Businesses rekey for the same reasons homeowners do, just more often: staff turnover, lost keys and tenant changes. Commercial rekeying is also the moment to fix key control, by building a master key system or moving important doors to a restricted keyway so keys can't be copied at a hardware store.
Keying alike and master keys
Rekeying is also how you simplify. Keyed alike means several locks open with the same key, which is ideal for a home's exterior doors. Master keying means each lock has its own key while one master key opens them all, which suits rentals, offices and multi-unit buildings.
Both are done with the same pins and the same visit, as long as the locks share a compatible keyway. If they don't, replacing a few cylinders or locks can bring everything onto one system.
A quick decision checklist
Ask three questions for each lock. Does it work smoothly every time? Is it strong enough for the door it's on? Do you need to control who can copy the key? If the first two answers are yes and the third is no, rekey. If either of the first two is no, replace. If the third is yes, choose a restricted or high-security cylinder while you're making the change.
Getting it done in Atlanta
Arrowhead Lock & Safe has rekeyed and replaced locks for Atlanta homes and businesses since 1973. Call 404-351-4331 and tell us how many doors and what kind of locks you have, and we'll recommend the right mix of rekeying and replacement.
Frequently asked questions
How long does rekeying take?
Usually a few minutes per lock once the technician is on site.
Can any lock be rekeyed?
Most pin-tumbler locks can. Some very cheap locks, damaged cylinders and certain specialty locks are better replaced.
More home & residential locks articles