Serving Atlanta since 1973 |Now hiring technicians

404-351-4331
ARROWHEADLOCK & SAFE INC.

Home & Residential Locks

Rekeying Locks to Use the Same Key

How to get one key for every door: keying alike, compatible keyways, mixing brands, and when a cylinder or lock swap is needed.

Updated November 21, 2026 · 3 min read · Arrowhead Lock & Safe

Why one key is worth it

Carrying separate keys for the front door, back door, garage entry and deadbolts is a nuisance, and it makes it hard to keep track of who can get in. Keying every exterior lock alike gives you a single key that opens everything. Family members carry one key, spares are simpler and rekeying in the future means one set of new keys instead of several.

Keyways decide what can match

A keyway is the shape of the slot in the cylinder and the matching profile of the key blank. Locks can only share a key if they share a keyway. Many common residential brands use a few popular keyways, and locks within the same keyway can usually be keyed alike. When a house has a mix of brands with different keyways, some cylinders need to be converted, replaced or swapped for compatible ones.

Converting mixed brands

Some locks accept cylinders from other manufacturers or have conversion options. In other cases, replacing an odd lock with one that matches the rest is the simplest route. A locksmith can look at your locks, identify their keyways and tell you which can be keyed together as they are and which need a change.

Deadbolts, knobs and handle sets

Each lock on a door has its own cylinder. A front door with a handle set and a deadbolt has two cylinders, and both need to be keyed. Back doors, side doors and garage entry doors add more. Storm door locks, gate locks and some padlocks can sometimes be keyed in too.

Adding smart or keypad locks

Many keypad and smart locks include a backup key cylinder that can be rekeyed to match your other doors. That way the same key works everywhere if a battery dies. Check the model before buying; some use proprietary cylinders that can't be matched.

Going restricted

If you're keying everything to one key anyway, consider a restricted keyway so copies can't be made without your permission. That's especially useful for landlords and homes where many people have had keys.

Keeping it simple after the rekey

Once every door uses one key, decide how many copies you need and who gets them. Label nothing with your address. Keep one spare locked away rather than hidden outside. If you later add a lock, such as a new storm door or shed, buy one with the same keyway so it can be keyed to match. That way the single-key setup lasts for years instead of slowly drifting back to a ring of mismatched keys.

One-visit service

Most homes can be keyed alike in a single visit. Bring cylinders to the shop to save on the service call if you prefer. Arrowhead keys locks alike for Atlanta homeowners and businesses. Call 404-351-4331.

Frequently asked questions

Can locks from different brands use one key?

Only if they share a compatible keyway, or after cylinder conversion or replacement.

Do I need new locks to key everything alike?

Often not. Many existing locks can be rekeyed to match.

Can a padlock match my house key?

Some padlocks use cylinders that can be keyed to match, depending on the keyway.

What if one lock can't match?

Replacing that one lock with a compatible model is usually simplest.

Can my smart lock match my other keys?

If its backup cylinder uses a compatible keyway, yes.

Let's secure what matters

Talk with an Atlanta security professional.